Is the partly-nonfiction Gay Talese book about the sex-peeping Colfax motelier any good?

Author Gay Talese disavowed his own book, but critics won’t!

Dave Burdick

Jul. 11, 2016, 12:57 p.m.

Hey! Remember when everybody got all fired up because of that book being written by famous journalist/author Gay Talese about a motel on Colfax owned by a guy who kept a notebook all about the sex he watched through peepholes he’d installed?

And remember when the peeper guy started getting death threats about it?

And remember when everybody got all fired up again because, wah-wah, it probably wasn’t all… true?

“I should not have believed a word he said,” the 84-year-old author said after The Washington Post informed him of property records that showed Foos did not own the motel from 1980 to 1988.

Well, do you wonder if “The Voyeur’s Motel” is any good?

USA Today: No, it’s gross.

NYT: No, but it feels like you’re really there with that creep and also we want to have it both ways.

Kirkus: Yes.

Publisher’s Weekly: Not really.

Verdict: Gay Talese disavowed his book, and then un-disavowed it — reavowed it? — and critics feel basically the same way.

Beer, seen here from inside the cooler at Argonaut Wine & Liquor, Colfax and Clarkson. (Kevin J. Beaty/Denverite)

Airbnb unleashes New Year’s Eve anti-party technology in Denver and beyond

In 2021, the company stopped more than 950 Denverites from ringing in the New Year at a short-term rental.

401 Madison St. in Denver's Cherry Creek neighborhood. Dec. 5, 2022.

Is this Cherry Creek house an eyesore or a historic gem? It depends who you ask.

Prominent architect Richard Crowther's home is up for preservation. For historians and architects it's important history. For the neighbors, it's “a brutal slab of concrete."

Denver mayoral candidate Trinidad Rodriguez presents his plan to address chronic homelessness.

Denver mayor candidate Trinidad Rodriguez would declare a “state of emergency” over homelessness and push for “involuntary holds” for mental health and addiction treatment

“I believe the catastrophe on our streets is principally driven by a series of health crises — not affordability in our city,” the longtime housing advocate said.

Mayor Hancock's deputy chief of staff Evan Dreyer speaks at a press conference in Denver's Emergency Operations Center, in the City and County Building basement. Dec. 8, 2022.

Denver doesn’t think the group of migrants who arrived this week was sent by another state government

Nonprofits at the southern U.S. border have already needed some help.

Canada Geese fly by cranes looming above Globeville Landing Park at dawn. April 23, 2021.

Denver recovered a record amount of wage theft money this year. Stronger protections for workers may be coming

The auditor’s office recovered more than $1 million in stolen wages in 2022.

Wrapped gifts fill a room at Heritage Lakewood Belmar Park, part of Lonnie Hanzon's Camp Christmas. Dec. 2, 2021.

Five Points and West Colfax are hoping people stop by to shop and donate

Tis the season.

An emergency shelter for people from the U.S. border, set up at an unnamed rec center.

Here’s what we know about the migrants that arrived in Denver on Monday

We still don't know how they got here.

Step Denver, a recovery program in Downtown Denver, December 7, 2022.

Step Denver: No-cost addiction treatment averages 63% capacity in the metro area

There are 179 addiction recovery beds currently available, according to the men's recovery center's latest data.

Play our version of Guess Who and get to know some mayoral candidates

This is a ploy to make you civically engaged.

Denver scrambled to help 100 migrants bused to the city without warning

At least one bus arrived on Monday night. It's unclear from where it originated.

The Yad Achas synagogue at 3500 W. Conejos Pl. in Denver's West Colfax neighborhood. Dec. 5, 2022.

As redevelopment encroaches on West Colfax’s Jewish history, some hope a cultural district will help preserve it

“We want to maintain some semblance of community here."

Aldwyn Gardener at City Park. Dec. 6, 2022.

IT professional Al Gardner, who has served on various boards across Denver, is running for mayor

He has served on the Denver Civil Service Commission, the Denver African American Commission, and the Citizen Oversight Board, among others.

Keith Clasen holds a bullet he found near his Barnum home. Nov. 18, 2022.

Gunfire is ringing across the city. These neighborhoods are where it’s the worst.

It's worse in the city's southwest corner, but gunshots can be heard across the city.

The Park Hill Golf Course. Sept. 14, 2022.

City Council passes a Park Hill Golf Course small area plan to make way for rezoning 155 acres of northeast Denver

At stake: whether a shuttered golf course can be turned into a massive mixed-use development.

A full recycling bin in Denver's Country Club neighborhood. Feb. 15, 2022.

Despite concerns, Denver’s ‘pay as you throw’ program is on track to start in January

In November, the auditor's office released a report saying the city isn't on track to successfully implement the new program. City Council just passed a contract with a private company to help raise capacity.